Similar to high-profile quarterbacks like Patrick Mahomes of the Kansas City Chiefs and Aaron Rodgers of the New York Jets, fantasy football managers are being advised to be cautious about selecting Indianapolis Colts quarterback Anthony Richardson. Based on his performance during the previous season, ESPN has suggested that fantasy managers consider other quarterbacks as their drafts approach.
Indianapolis Colts’ general manager, Chris Ballard, has expressed expectations for a roller-coaster season for Richardson in his second year. Ballard foresees a mixture of highs and lows as Richardson becomes more acquainted with the offensive schemes of head coach Shane Steichen. According to Ballard, Richardson’s rookie year was marked by both promising moments and inevitable growing pains due to his limited experience. The young quarterback demonstrated his potential through a strong arm and notable rushing skills, but he will need more time to refine his game and adapt to the NFL’s demands.
Richardson, who started only four games during his rookie season, showed glimpses of his capabilities but also faced significant challenges. His performance was characterized by both impressive plays and struggles, a reflection of his ongoing development. Colts’ general manager Ballard believes that with additional game experience, Richardson will enhance his decision-making skills and improve his ability to protect himself on the field.
As the Colts prepare for the 2024 season, Richardson’s progress and health are critical to the team’s success. His preseason performances have been a mix of encouraging signs and areas needing improvement. Ballard highlights that Richardson’s ability to navigate the complexities of professional football will grow as he gains more experience.
In the realm of fantasy football, the new season is prompting managers to finalize their rosters. Erick Karabell of ESPN has provided an analysis suggesting that Richardson might not be the best pick for fantasy teams. According to Karabell, Richardson’s performance in his rookie season has made him one of the more divisive options at quarterback. Despite his potential as an elite runner and his impressive physical attributes—standing 6-foot-4 and weighing 244 pounds—his rookie season was marred by injuries, including a concussion and a shoulder injury that cut his season short before Halloween.
Karabell points out that Richardson’s future health is a significant concern. With the depth available at the quarterback position in fantasy football, it might be wiser to avoid drafting Richardson in the early rounds. Instead, fantasy managers might find more value in waiting for proven quarterbacks like Joe Burrow or Kyler Murray, who are available later in drafts.
In addition to health concerns, Richardson’s accuracy has been a point of criticism. Analysis from the past season revealed that his completion rate was around 54% in college and dropped below 50% on non-screen passes in the NFL. Furthermore, over 21% of his throws last season were classified as bad throws, which raises questions about his development and potential impact for fantasy teams.
In summary, while Anthony Richardson has shown potential as a quarterback with a strong arm and dynamic rushing ability, his rookie season was marked by significant challenges, including injuries and accuracy issues. For fantasy football managers, these factors suggest that Richardson might not be the most reliable choice, especially when more proven and stable options are available. As the draft approaches, it might be prudent to consider other quarterbacks who offer a higher level of consistency and reliability.
