Arch Manning’s popularity has been a hot topic, and many wonder what exactly is behind it. As a quarterback who hasn’t yet been the primary starter, some argue that his famous surname plays a big role in the spotlight he’s in. Being the nephew of Super Bowl-winning quarterbacks Peyton and Eli Manning, and the grandson of College Football Hall of Famer Archie Manning, certainly has its advantages. However, a famous last name alone doesn’t guarantee a successful career. In Arch’s case, he’s worked hard to carve out his own identity beyond the Manning legacy. Still, some critics remain skeptical about his abilities—more on that later.
Before we dive into the criticisms, it’s important to note that Arch wasn’t handed anything on a silver platter. For two challenging seasons, the 19-year-old quarterback stayed in the background, observing his predecessor, Quinn Ewers. Yet, every time the team needed a backup, Arch was ready. In his debut against Colorado State, Arch made an instant impact by throwing a touchdown pass and rushing for another, pushing Texas to a commanding 52-0 lead. His performance against UTSA was equally impressive, stepping in for an injured Ewers and quickly making key plays, including a 67-yard touchdown run and a 75-yard touchdown pass, all while breaking a speed record set by Tyreek Hill.
These performances showcased Arch’s potential, but not everyone is convinced. Despite the promising start, when ESPN released its list of top 15 quarterbacks in college football for 2025, Arch found himself ranked surprisingly low at 12th. Why such a ranking for someone with so much potential? According to the list, first-year starters like Arch are often overlooked in favor of more experienced players. For context, Cade Klubnik of Clemson took the top spot, with an impressive season of 3,639 passing yards and 36 touchdowns.
Interestingly, just days after the ranking, ESPN published a highlight reel of Arch Manning’s best plays, including his performances against Colorado State, UTSA, and others, noting that many are already pegging him as a Heisman contender for the 2025 season. Despite his relatively short career, the upcoming season is expected to be pivotal for Arch, and it’s clear that his journey is just beginning.
As for why Arch was ranked 12th, it’s largely due to his limited playing time and the fact that other quarterbacks had more extensive experience on the field. Coaches, however, acknowledge his impressive athleticism and raw talent. “He’s an elite athlete,” one coach said, adding that he’s still a first-time starter, so more time on the field will be crucial for his development.
Still, the ranking didn’t sit well with everyone. Brad Kellner of Locked on Longhorns expressed his frustration with Arch being placed so low, especially considering Texas’s high expectations for both him and the team. Given that Arch is currently among the favorites to win the Heisman and Texas has strong national championship aspirations, many feel the ranking was an oversight.
Arch Manning’s situation is one of great promise, but also immense pressure. As Texas’s quarterback, he’s expected to live up to the hype surrounding him—not just from fans, but from head coach Steve Sarkisian as well. While his career is still in its early stages, it’s clear that 2025 is a critical year for Arch to solidify his place in the college football landscape. Fans are hoping to see him rise higher in future rankings and prove that he’s more than just a product of his family’s legacy.