The Cincinnati Reds have pressing needs as the trade deadline approaches, and there are viable options on the market to address them. Let’s explore a targeted strategy that GM Nick Krall and his team can take to make smart, impactful moves.
This approach focuses on players who meet three essential criteria:
1. Availability:
We’re not talking about fantasy acquisitions like Mike Trout—whose team, the Angels, may still consider themselves in the AL Wild Card race. Instead, we’re focused on players from likely sellers.
2. Reasonable Cost:
Take, for instance, a suggestion by former GM Jim Bowden—a deal involving Chase Petty and other prospects for Ryan O’Hearn of the Orioles. While O’Hearn would improve the Reds’ lineup, that price is steep for a rental-level bat. Petty and top prospects should only be dealt for significant returns.
3. Proven Fit:
We’re looking at contributors with established value who fill actual needs—not prospects or lateral trades.
Target: Dane Myers, OF, Miami Marlins
Myers may not be a household name, but the numbers speak volumes—and favorably compare even to a popular trade target like Luis Robert Jr. from the White Sox:
| Player | G | AVG/OBP/SLG | wRC+ | DRS | Control |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Myers | 50 | .320/.371/.456 | 124 | +5 | Through 2029 |
| Robert Jr. | 72 | .185/.270/.313 | 63 | -2 | $20M options (2026–27) |
Against left-handed pitching, where Cincinnati desperately needs help, Myers has a 186 wRC+ in 60 plate appearances. That alone should raise eyebrows.
Cost Efficiency
Robert Jr. will cost a premium as the White Sox are aiming to restock their farm system. On the other hand, Myers, despite being 29, offers team control through 2029 and should require a much smaller package.
Giving up Chase Petty for Myers may seem steep at first glance, but it’s far more justifiable than trading him for a one-year rental like O’Hearn:
| Player | G | AVG/OBP/SLG | wRC+ | DRS | FA |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| O’Hearn | 66 | .304/.385/.489 | 150 | -3 | 2024 |
Vs. LHP:
- Myers: .382/.433/.600 (186 wRC+)
- O’Hearn: .233/.327/.279 (82 wRC+)
Verdict: Go Get Dane Myers
He’s cost-effective, fills a major need, and is performing at a high level. If Cincinnati wants to boost its playoff odds, especially against left-handed pitching, Myers should be at the top of their trade board.