The Cleveland Guardians experienced a standout season from Josh Naylor in 2024, showcasing impressive statistics that underscored his development as a key player. Following a solid performance in 2023, where he posted an .843 OPS, Naylor broke through in 2024 by exceeding the 30-home run mark for the first time in his career. He finished the season with 31 home runs and drove in an impressive 108 runs, solidifying his role as a vital offensive contributor.
Despite Naylor’s success, the Guardians are known for their strategic approach regarding player contracts. Historically, when a player’s salary begins to escalate as they near free agency, the Guardians often opt to trade them. This strategy allows the team to extract value while avoiding the financial commitment of a long-term contract extension.
.@DreKnott talks about Josh Naylor's future with the Cleveland Guardians…
"Everybody loves Josh but there's always a sign with the Cleveland baseball team…" pic.twitter.com/oJyybFRJDA
— ESPN Cleveland (@ESPNCleveland) October 21, 2024
Team reporter Andre Knott hinted at this possibility for Naylor, commenting on his future with the Guardians. As shared by ESPN Cleveland on X, Knott noted, “Everyone loves Josh, but there’s always a sign with the Cleveland baseball team,” suggesting that Naylor may not be a long-term fixture.
Given the Guardians’ financial landscape, it seems unlikely that they would be willing to pay the premium typically associated with first basemen. Therefore, trading Naylor could be a feasible option. Although he may not be a significant on-base threat—his OPS falling below .800—his ability to hit 30 home runs and drive in over 100 runs makes him an attractive target for other teams.
The Guardians are also well-positioned for a potential trade due to the emergence of Kyle Manzardo, who is ready to step into the first base role. Additionally, Ralphy Velazquez, a promising talent in the lower minors, adds to the depth at the position. Both players could provide affordable production at first base, allowing the Guardians the flexibility to move Naylor in exchange for pitching help, a critical area of need for the team.
While the prospect of extending Naylor’s contract is still on the table, it appears highly unlikely given the Guardians’ established practices. The combination of Naylor’s breakout performance and the Guardians’ strategic tendencies creates a complex situation that could lead to significant changes in the offseason. As the team looks to balance immediate competitiveness with long-term financial health, the future of Josh Naylor remains uncertain but undoubtedly pivotal for the Guardians’ direction moving forward.