The Cleveland Guardians’ playoff journey came to an abrupt end on Saturday night, as they lost to the New York Yankees in the AL Championship Series, concluding the series in five games. This loss was particularly disappointing for a team that had fought hard to earn the title of AL Central champions.
The Guardians showcased their resilience in a dramatic Game 3, where rookie Jhonkensy Noel hit a game-tying two-run homer in the ninth inning. His clutch performance was followed by a game-winning two-run shot from David Fry in extra innings, bringing hope to Guardians fans. However, that momentum proved fleeting. The Yankees quickly regrouped and secured victories in both Game 4 and Game 5, with Juan Soto delivering a decisive blow—a three-run homer in the tenth inning of Game 5 that clinched the series for New York.
Despite the disappointing end, the 2024 season was a marked improvement for the Cleveland Guardians compared to the previous year. In 2023, the team struggled with a 76-86 record, finishing third in the AL Central. Under the guidance of first-year manager Stephen Vogt, the Guardians rebounded impressively, posting a strong 92-69 record this season and securing the second-best record in the American League.
With the conclusion of the 2024 season, the focus now shifts to the 2025 campaign. The Guardians have a relatively stable core, with few key free agents needing re-signing. However, one of the biggest decisions looms over Shane Bieber, the former AL Cy Young Award winner, who made only two starts this season before undergoing Tommy John surgery in April. His health and performance moving forward will be crucial to the team’s rotation plans.
Tanner Bibee emerged as a reliable ace during the season, raising questions about whether the Cleveland Guardians should pursue another starting pitcher instead of committing to Bieber, who has struggled with injuries in recent years. In 2023, he managed just 21 starts due to elbow issues, and his two starts in 2024 saw him record an impressive 20 strikeouts in 12 innings, highlighting his potential when healthy.
Bieber’s uncertain future complicates matters, as Spotrac.com estimates his market value at a six-year, $147.2 million deal. However, given his injury history, it seems unlikely he will command such a contract. A short-term deal might be more feasible, allowing the Guardians to maintain a solid rotation while they await his return. Meanwhile, the team hopes for a resurgence from Triston McKenzie, who faced his own struggles and spent time in the minors this season.
In summary, while the Cleveland Guardians’ playoff run ended in disappointment, their significant progress in 2024 provides a strong foundation for the future. The decisions they make this offseason, particularly regarding Shane Bieber and their pitching staff, will be pivotal as they aim to build on this season’s success.