The Indianapolis Colts’ defense had its share of ups and downs after the 2023 season concluded. While the unit showcased its potential at times, it struggled significantly, finishing 28th in points allowed per game (24.4). This performance was attributed to a combination of youthful inexperience, injuries, and gaps in Gus Bradley’s defensive scheme. Looking ahead to 2024, there’s optimism about the lessons learned and the development potential of rookies like standout cornerbacks JuJu Brents and Jaylon Jones.
Despite the progress, there’s always room for improvement in bolstering the Colts’ defensive lineup. Could a major trade be in the works to enhance their roster? NFL analyst Ryan Fowler from Bleacher Report proposes a blockbuster scenario where the Colts acquire Jonathan Allen, a two-time Pro Bowl defensive tackle, from the Washington Commanders.
Adding a player of Jonathan Allen’s caliber could potentially elevate the Colts in the competitive AFC. Known for his prowess as a three-down defensive tackle, Allen is a formidable force on the interior, as noted by Fowler. Last season, he recorded 5.5 sacks, 53 tackles, 10 tackles for loss, and 49 quarterback pressures according to Pro Football Focus, making him a valuable addition alongside DeForest Buckner in the Colts’ pass rush.
However, there are practical considerations to weigh. Allen commands a significant salary of $18 million annually, a financial commitment that contrasts with the Colts’ conservative approach to roster management. Additionally, any trade for Allen would likely involve relinquishing future draft picks (a 2025 second-round pick and a 2026 fourth-round pick), along with assuming his remaining contract costs of $29.5 million through 2025.
Moreover, Allen’s performance in run defense has been criticized, registering a subpar grade of 37.9 by Pro Football Focus on run defense snaps. This raises concerns, especially when compared to Colts’ defensive linemen like Raekwon Davis and Grover Stewart, who excel in this aspect of the game.
While Fowler’s proposal highlights the need for Indianapolis to bolster its pass rush against AFC South quarterbacks like C.J. Stroud, Trevor Lawrence, and Will Levis, recent additions like rookie Laiatu Latu may already address this need. Latu, considered one of the NFL’s most pro-ready defenders from the latest draft, brings potential solutions to the Colts’ defensive strategy for the upcoming season.
In conclusion, while the idea of acquiring Jonathan Allen could theoretically enhance the Colts’ defensive capabilities, practical considerations around salary, draft assets, and fit within the team’s defensive scheme may ultimately deter such a move as Indianapolis prepares for the 2024 season.