In the opening month of the 2024 Major League Baseball season, the New York Yankees showcased formidable offensive prowess despite Aaron Judge’s initial struggles. They surged to a 19-10 record, averaging over five runs per game.
May saw Judge’s resurgence and an impressive run from the starting rotation, which boasted a remarkable 2.02 ERA across 28 starts. Luis Gil, originally a stopgap until Gerrit Cole’s return, emerged as a Cy Young contender with seven consecutive starts allowing one run or less.
By June 12, the Yankees led the league with a 49-21 record, scoring 356 runs while conceding just 228. With Cole set to return, optimism abounded in the Bronx.
Fast forward to now?
The Yankees are in free fall.
“Hopefully we can add some outside pieces that will benefit us at some point,” said Yankees GM Brian Cashman recently.
Their plummeting season dominates recent discussions, prompting the question: Can they salvage this chaos?
What Went Wrong?
The Yankees have stumbled to a 6-17 record in their last 23 games, the worst in baseball.
The blame falls heavily on the offense, now reliant on Judge and Juan Soto amidst a struggling lineup. Rookie Ben Rice has been a bright spot, but overall, support is lacking.
Pitching has been equally disastrous. Following their stellar May, the rotation’s glory has faded. Marcus Stroman, the second-best starter recently, posted a 6.43 ERA over his last four outings. Cole (6.75 ERA), Gil (7.59 ERA), and Carlos Rodón (10.80 ERA) have also faltered.
Closer Clay Holmes mirrors Rodón’s struggles, blowing both save opportunities in the past month. Collectively, the Yankees haven’t converted a save since June 10.
From early-season dominance to current disarray, parallels to their 2022 collapse are stark. After starting 61-23, they limped to the ALCS exit.
To prevent history from repeating, the Yankees must address glaring weaknesses.
“We definitely have areas to improve upon, and we’ll do our best to do so,” Cashman noted.
While specifics weren’t outlined, three critical needs are evident.
Second Base and Third Base
The Yankees are underperforming at both positions, lacking offensive punch and defensive prowess.
Mike Francesca suggested a trade for Jeff McNeil, but doubts linger over his recent form and pricey contract.
Matt Chapman of the Giants emerges as a potential solution. Despite contract complexities, his defensive acumen and slugging could transform the Yankees’ infield dynamics.
Luis Rengifo of the Angels presents a more financially viable option, boasting versatility and a solid bat.
Outfield
Alex Verdugo’s decline underscores the need for outfield reinforcement.
Luis Robert Jr., the White Sox standout, offers a potent offensive boost and long-term stability.
Jazz Chisholm Jr. of the Marlins provides another intriguing option, despite a less prolific batting record than Robert.
Brent Rooker of the Athletics, with an affordable contract and impressive offensive stats, could also fortify their lineup.
Left-Handed Reliever / Closer
Tanner Scott, the Marlins’ standout left-handed closer, emerges as a pivotal target to bolster their bullpen.
Despite previous acquisitions not panning out, Scott’s standout performance makes him an attractive addition.
The Yankees’ approach at the deadline remains uncertain. Despite holding a top-five farm system, financial constraints loom large.
Their hefty payroll could balloon further, complicating aggressive moves. Yet, their status in the AL East playoff picture remains promising.
A cautious yet strategic approach might suffice, with additions like Rengifo, Rooker, and Scott offering potential fixes without excessive financial strain.
Failure to address these issues risks backlash from a passionate fanbase craving a return to championship glory.
The Yankees face a pivotal juncture. Their decisions in the coming weeks could dictate their postseason fate and long-term aspirations.